Uncategorized

New York Pet Owners Targeted by AI Scam While Searching for Missing Dogs

For three weeks, Jennifer Wheeler and her partner, Chris Cooper, searched for their dogs, Copper and Oscar.

The pair slipped out of the couple’s home in Naples, New York, on July 6. It wasn’t the first time.

“Well, they’re escape artists,” Wheeler said. “They can open doors and windows.”

Usually, they don’t stay lost for long. Out in the country, a neighbor’s trail camera typically spots them within the hour.

Copper and Oscar. Courtesy of Chris Cooper.

This time, nobody did. Wheeler and Cooper knocked on doors, called shelters, hired drone crews and offered a reward. About 20 days into the search, Wheeler’s phone rang.

A man calling from a Michigan number said the dogs were sitting in his living room. When Wheeler asked for proof, he sent a photo. To her, it was Copper and Oscar.

“I ran and told my boyfriend… we were both like, oh my god, this is awesome,” Wheeler said. “And we may have gotten a little teary-eyed.”

The excitement didn’t last. The caller wanted the full $1,000 reward through Cash App or Venmo before he would release the dogs.

“The minute they said they wanted the money before I could get my dogs, I knew for sure,” Wheeler said.

She refused to pay and called the sheriff’s office. Deputies came to the house and looked at the photo. Wheeler said one of the younger officers spotted something she hadn’t.

“They said they thought it was AI right off, because it was too perfect,” she said. “The background pictures, like the bookshelves in the back, everything was just perfect. And the dogs kind of blended together.”

Looking back, Wheeler said one detail seemed off: Copper appeared to be asleep. But she had been focused on her dogs, not the room behind them. A detection tool her daughter suggested later flagged the image as almost certainly AI-generated. Such tools aren’t foolproof, and the image’s origin has not been independently confirmed.

“So now I feel like an idiot, because I was totally scammed,” Wheeler said. “AI could be great, but giving it to the wrong hands, it’s very dangerous.”

Micah Winburn, a security engineer at CooperRiis, a residential treatment center in North Carolina, also helps oversee how the center uses AI. He said scams like this work because they catch people at their most emotional moment.

“If you’re missing your dogs for a few weeks and then somebody reaches out saying I have your dogs, here’s evidence that I have your dogs, you’re going to be overcome with joy,” Winburn said. “You’re probably not going to be thinking, oh, is this a scam?”

Wheeler’s case fits a larger pattern. In 2026, the FBI’s annual internet crime report included a section on AI for the first time, counting more than 22,000 AI-related complaints in 2025 with reported losses of nearly $900 million. The bureau warns that scammers pair AI with pressure tactics to push people to act before they can check the facts. Its advice: take a beat.

Wheeler and Cooper are still looking for Copper and Oscar. The reward has grown to $3,500.

“Those are our babies,” Wheeler said. “It was really, really heartbreaking. It still is. We still have hope.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *