Uncategorized

The Effects of AI: Education

Photo Credit: Jayson Bradley

A recent study released by the Center for Democracy and Technology showed that 85% of teachers and 86% of students were found to be using AI in the 2024-2025 school year.

One of those students who uses AI in her studies is 14-year-old Aubrey, a student at Barton Middle School.

“Whenever I have homework, I use it to explain and summarize,” she said. “It can give me the same answer as, like, the thing [textbook], but it’s easier to find the answer quicker.”

Aubrey admitted that she is less likely to remember information she attains through the chat model as opposed to classic textbook research.

“I probably remember less because when I get the answer, I just, like, put it down quicker,” she said. “I don’t have to do the work to find the solutions. I wrote about this too. It can take away creativity or something like that. Like, it takes away your creativity by having it generate it for you.”

This powerful new software has broadly affected many sectors and industries across the world, for better or for worse. Chat models, or LLM’s have some benefits when used appropriately, however recent data and professional analyses indicate that overreliance on such tools can have a hugely adverse effect on developing minds and the efficacy of the U.S. education system.

Rebecca Winthrop, a senior fellow and director of the Center for Universal Education at the Brookings Institution co-authored an analysis on the effects of AI in relation to youth education. The findings of the report reinforce many experts’ beliefs that the overuse of this technology is very negatively affecting developing minds’ ability to absorb information and think critically.

“When kids use generative AI that tells them what the answer is … they are not thinking for themselves,” according to Winthrop’s analysis. “They’re not learning to parse truth from fiction. They’re not learning to understand what makes a good argument. They’re not learning about different perspectives in the world because they’re actually not engaging in the material.“

This problem is further exacerbated by the fact that schools are trying to implement this technology into the curriculum instead of refuting and admonishing it. The report by Winthrop also found that proper implementation of the software has increased student engagement and professional development. According to the report, 59% of teachers said AI allowed them to deliver more personalized learning to their students and 55% said it allowed them to have more time for direct interaction with students.

An overreliance on this technology by kids who have not fully developed literacy skills and reading comprehension only serves to stunt their academic growth and cognition. Jared Cooney Horvath, a neuroscientist for LME Global presented his findings in a written testimony before the U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation. His research found that Gen Z is “less cognitively capable than previous generations, despite its unprecedented access to technology… Gen Z is the first generation in modern history to score lower on standardized tests than the previous one.”

Horvath’s report also states that, “multiple indicators show decline in literacy, numeracy, problem solving, creativity, and general cognitive performance among adolescents.” This coincides with a correlation between children spending more than four hours on screens during a normal school day while only using said technology for schoolwork less than half of that time.

This is not an isolated event contained within the United States. The Programme for International Student Assessment reviewing a dozen other countries showed data that parallels that of our own: an extreme decline in literacy, numeracy, and cognition among adolescents. The data indicates that, “frequent in-class computer [usage] correlates with significantly lower math and science performance across both high-income and middle-income countries.”

“A majority will use it [AI], when possible,” Nick Pesek, a secondary teacher at Barton Middle School, said. “A major reason why most schools are going away from homework is because none of it is the students’ authentic work. It turns out to be a waste of time.”

Pesek’s sentiment aligns with the research findings by Horvath and Winthrop.

“They are losing critical thinking skills,” Pesek said. “I worry more about the future of under qualified people getting jobs over much more deserving people because of the use of AI. Authenticity is going to be very difficult to filter for.”

To combat this, some teachers, including Pesek, have begun a transition back to using less technology for certain assignments.

“We transitioned back to paper,” Pesek said. “My classroom is 50/50 with use of technology and paper copies.”

“I think it’s important not to replace the critical thinking in the core kind of mastery of skills that you may have and outsource it to our products so I think what I mean by that is it’s great to use these tools to save you time or to make you more efficient or more productive,” Mitchell Bradley, an account director at OpenAI said. “At the end of the day, overreliance, I think, ultimately strips the ability to be able to think or act or maintain these sorts of skills for yourself.”

Bradley said that AI use has its pros and cons with delegating tasks such as research, writing first drafts, and using it as a peer editor ranking among the pros, which allows users to spend more time on high leverage work and creativity.

“Before the Internet, the only way you could learn about things is from books,” Bradley said. “What if you don’t live near a library? What if you don’t have parents who can drive you to the library? What if the library near you doesn’t carry the books. Then the Internet democratized access to information. People across the world now have access to intelligence in their pocket, and so I think the barrier to entry to being able to make meaningful contributions has never been easier. The negatives or the downside is that I think it’s never been more important to be human and what I mean by that is when anyone has access to intelligence, everyone has access to intelligence, and therefore the ability to differentiate to distinguish yourself having taste has never been more important, especially in things that are inherently creative. Like they say in Spider-Man, ‘with great power comes responsibility.’ You need to be able to use these tools effectively and not ultimately let them cannibalize your ability to be human.”

Bradley emphasized the importance of not introducing this tech too early to developing minds, “It’s not great to give a young kid an iPad all day every day and I think in similar ways how we allow kids to leverage this technology is important so that you’re striking the right balance between allowing them to learn and apply critical thinking to their studies but not becoming overly reliant at such a young age that they can’t cultivate these sorts of skills for themselves. Maintaining critical thinking and being able to learn and think for yourself is super important and I think that these tools may conflict with kids’ ability to build those strong connections in their heads early on and it’s probably not something that they should be relying on until they’re old enough to know better.”

LLM’s are a developing technology, and Winthrop, Horvath, Pesek, and Bradley all agree that this tech and the usage of it isn’t going away; its usage is only accelerating; and it is more important than ever that it is used responsibly and appropriately to ensure that developing minds don’t lose their ability to think for themselves.

Photo Credit: Jayson Bradley

Citations

Academic Integrity and Teaching With(out) AI. Harvard University. (n.d.). https://secretary.college.harvard.edu/academic-integrity-and-teaching-without-ai/

Horvath, J. C. (2026). Written Testimony. Commerce Senate. https://www.commerce.senate.gov/services/files/A19DF2E8-3C69-4193-A676-430CF0C83DC2

Ma, J. (2026, August 30). It’s not just math and reading. classroom devices deprive kids of skills needed in the AI future and how to be “fully human,” education experts say. Fortune. https://fortune.com/2026/08/30/classroom-devices-backlash-online-learning-test-scores-cognition-human-skills-ai-future/

Morgan, J. M., Potter, H., & Edwards, A. (2026, August 25). Americans are united against the Tech takeover of Public Schools. The Century Foundation. https://tcf.org/content/report/americans-are-united-against-the-tech-takeover-of-public-schools/

Sidoti, O., Park, E., & Gottfried, J. (2025, January 15). Share of teens using CHATGPT for schoolwork doubled from 2023 to 2024. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/01/15/about-a-quarter-of-us-teens-have-used-chatgpt-for-schoolwork-double-the-share-in-2023/

Vilcarino, J., & Langreo, L. (2025, October 8). Rising use of AI in schools comes with big downsides for students. Education Week. https://www.edweek.org/technology/rising-use-of-ai-in-schools-comes-with-big-downsides-for-students/2025/10

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *